It is amazing to recognize how quickly our minds try to make sense of other people.
Someone responds differently than we expected, and, almost immediately, we begin constructing an explanation. We notice a change in someone's tone, an expression we can't quite interpret, or a response that feels unusually brief, and before we've had much opportunity to consider the possibilities, we've often settled on a story about what it means.
Sometimes those stories are accurate. Other times, they're informed more by our own experiences, expectations, and insecurities than by anything the other person intended to communicate.
Lately, my social work coursework has had me thinking about the difference between recognizing what someone might be experiencing and assuming that I understand why they're experiencing it. In Practice with Individuals, Families, and Groups, we've been exploring empathy, interpretation, and the ways that helping professionals can support clients in developing a deeper understanding of their own experiences. One concept that has particularly interested me is additive empathy, which involves thoughtfully identifying feelings, meanings, or patterns that may be present but haven't yet been fully expressed.
How we frame things shapes how we understand them.
I think this is where empathy becomes more complicated than we sometimes acknowledge: we often describe empathy as putting ourselves in someone else's shoes, which is a useful starting point, but I've never been entirely satisfied with that description. Even if I imagine myself in another person's circumstances, I'm still bringing my own history, values, assumptions, and emotional responses into the exercise. I'm imagining what I might feel in their position, which isn't necessarily what they're feeling at all. We’re all projecting, all of the time.
Two people can experience remarkably similar circumstances and understand them in entirely different ways. Something that feels disappointing to one person might feel relieving to another. A decision that appears frightening from the outside may represent freedom, stability, or an important personal achievement to the person making it.
Our ability to recognize a familiar situation doesn't automatically give us access to someone else's internal experience.
This is particularly important when working with people whose experiences differ significantly from our own, but I think it matters just as much in our closest relationships. Familiarity can create its own assumptions. We become accustomed to someone's patterns and begin believing we know what their behavior means before they've had an opportunity to explain it.
Sometimes we're right, but being right occasionally isn't the same as being curious consistently.
Of course, curiosity doesn't require ignoring patterns, dismissing our instincts, or repeatedly questioning ourselves when someone's behavior is harmful. There are circumstances where the information we already have is sufficient to establish a boundary or make a decision about our well-being.
But when understanding is possible and appropriate, I think there's tremendous value in allowing another person to be the authority on their own experience.
This is something I hope to continue practicing as I develop my work in social work and coaching. I want to become increasingly comfortable offering thoughtful observations while remaining genuinely willing to discover that I've missed something important.
Looking for support on your own journey?
You don't have to figure it all out alone. At Rewoven Life Coaching, I offer a compassionate, judgment-free space to explore where you are, where you want to be, and how to move forward in a way that feels authentic to you.
Book a free consultation to see if we're a good fit. I'd love to connect!